Why your board doesn't trust your communication numbers

T

here is a moment many people who look after communication know well. The agenda item comes up, and the treasurer or the chair asks, quite kindly: “So what are we getting from all this communication?”

You show the slide with the reach, the followers and the open rate. The numbers are good. The room stays polite, the meeting moves on, and you leave knowing that the question wasn't answered.

I have seen this in large companies and in small organisations. In my experience the work is rarely the problem. The numbers answer a different question from the one the board asked.

Busy is not the same as useful

Most teams count what is easy to count: posts, impressions, followers, opens and clicks. These figures show that communication is happening, and they have their place in the team's own planning.

A board asks something else. It wants to know what changed because of the work. Did donors stay? Did the partner sign? Did enough people come to the event, and were they the right ones? Did good candidates apply?

A newsletter is something you produce. A renewed donation is something that changes. Boards care about the second kind, and in organisations where every euro for communication competes with the programme, they are right to.

Why most reports stay with the easy numbers

There are three reasons, and none of them is laziness.

The useful numbers are in someone else's files. Whether donors renew is in the fundraising database, and who applied is with whoever does the hiring. The communication person often has no access, and nobody thought to give it.

Nobody agreed what success means. If the board never said what it expects communication to contribute, any report is a guess, and it gets judged against expectations that were never spoken.

It feels risky. Followers always go up a little. A number that is tied to a real goal can go down. Many people report what they can defend, and I understand why.

What a board finds convincing

You don't need a dashboard with twenty figures. Three to five are enough, and each one should sit close to a goal of the organisation. For example:

  • Donors, members or clients who stayed. How many renewed this year compared with last year?
  • Enquiries that came through your channels. How many partners, funders or clients first got in touch because of something you published?
  • Applications. Where did good candidates hear about you?
  • Sign-ups and attendance. How many people came, and who were they?
  • Trust. A short yearly survey with the same three questions shows over time whether people understand what you do.

It is rarely possible to prove that one newsletter caused one donation, and you don't have to. A board accepts a plausible connection that is reported in the same way every time.

Three questions to start with

Before you build anything, take these three questions to your director or chair:

  1. Which two or three goals of the organisation should communication support this year?
  2. Which figure would show us, for each goal, that we are getting closer?
  3. Who has that figure, and can I see it every month?

This conversation takes an hour. Afterwards you know what to report, and the board has said out loud what it expects. In most organisations nobody had ever said it before.

Then report those few figures on one page, in the same order, every time, with one sentence each on what they mean and what you will do next.

Once the page is in place, the board discusses what to do next with communication. You no longer have to defend the budget with anecdotes.

If you would like to prepare that conversation or the one-page report together, book a free intro call.

Smiling woman with curly blonde hair, wearing glasses, a white top, and a necklace with a round pendant.

Connect with Kristin!

Follow me on LinkedIn for practical thoughts on clear messages, AI in everyday communication and the work of small teams.

Notes from AliveCo
straight to your inbox!

@-Symbol icon in black.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Sign up for Notes from AliveCo, my newsletter.